Opinion: The campaign is only the beginning

The author makes a case for aligning creative promises with customer experiences across every touchpoint.

Vipul Arora

Nov 19, 2026, 9:08 am

Vipul Arora

A campaign can make someone curious enough to walk into a store. What happens next often depends on whether a member of staff can explain the offer that brought them in. It feels a long way from the creative brief, but it’s the moment a customer finds out whether the brand meant what it said.

I’ve spent a good part of my career in rooms asking what will make a campaign memorable. I’ve come to believe we should spend just as long asking what people will remember once they’ve actually dealt with the brand.

Advertising gives people a reason to pay attention. A consistent experience gives them a reason to come back.

Consistency is something customers feel

When we talk about consistency, we usually mean identity: the same colours, tone of voice and visual language everywhere. Those things help people recognise a brand. But customers also notice whether the brand behaves in a way they recognise.

Take a retailer that promises to make shopping simpler. The campaign shows how easy it is to find the right product. Online, that promise means comparing options without opening five tabs. In the store, it means finding the product at the price they saw on their phone. After the purchase, it means knowing exactly how to return it. Each moment needs its own solution. Together, they tell the customer whether the promise was real.

The gaps show most when people move between channels. Someone starts on their phone, buys in a store and calls support a week later. Inside the company, three teams may own those moments. The customer just remembers one experience.

The brief needs to reach further

For us as an agency, this changes what we ask at the start of a relationship. Where is the promise already visible in the experience? Where are customers likely to hit friction? Who can actually fix it? Those answers matter as much to the work as the audience insight behind the campaign.

So we need digital, retail and service teams in the room while the strategy is still taking shape. A store team may know that customers struggle to choose between two near-identical products. That could shape the campaign idea, and the idea could in turn inform a comparison tool online or a clearer display in the aisle. The creative opportunity may be to give people the confidence to choose, wherever they happen to be shopping.

We can also help brand teams agree on what the promise looks like in practice. A brand that stands for simplicity can ask a plain question of every new interaction: can the customer tell what to do next? A shared question like that helps teams make good calls in their own channels.

It changes how we judge our work too. Reach and recall tell us whether the campaign got through. What people ask in stores, where they give up online and whether they come back tell us where to look harder at the experience. Those signals help creative and operations teams decide, together, what to fix.

The campaign still has a vital job. It gives a brand a distinctive way to say what it stands for and invites people to see for themselves. But the real test comes in the ordinary moments that follow, when someone needs an answer, wants to compare two options or tries to return something. If the brand shows up then, the customer has a reason to believe the next thing it says.

The author is senior vice president, business and growth, Makani Creatives.

Source: MANIFEST MEDIA

Subscribe

* indicates required