Opinion: The death of safe advertising

The author argues that brands must move beyond predictable advertising and take creative risks again.

Shayondeep Pal

Nov 17, 2026, 10:32 am

Shayondeep Pal

As we were growing up in advertising, there used to be an air of excitement in conference rooms every time a bunch of creative guys would present routes or ideas to account management, as if the next Cannes Lions was unfurling in some corner of Okhla or Lower Parel or Kensington Road. The conviction and the wry smile pasted on a creative’s face was a treat to watch. It captured a feeling.

"Minions, you are about to witness greatness."

Halfway into the meeting, a client services director or an associate vice president would barge in with black coffee, pick up the last crumbs of the idea and join the dots. She would nod wisely and play with her newly acquired Sheaffer. "Guys, I like the idea, but I think we should carry an option that's in her mind."

The 'her', in this case, was the client. The CSD or AVP would never utter the words 'safe option' but would masquerade it with a game called 'second guessing'. Nothing wrong. She wanted the work to get approved without the flying stinkers.

Unfortunately, that's when the balance in an agency began to shift. Two creative routes and one safe route became the norm. The safe route was hidden in the presentation and would magically resurface with a reassuring smile as the conversation veered towards the safe option.

"There's too much riding on this one, guys. We can't get it wrong."

In fact, the comment above is reason enough for brands to take creative risks again. Let's deconstruct the sentence: There's too much riding on this one. We can't get it wrong.

Imagine an ODI World Cup semifinal. India are four wickets down. 220-odd runs in 96 balls is quite an uphill task. Virat Kohli is still at the crease. A lot is riding on him. How will he play? Will he bring out his A game and get the job done? Will he take aerial risks? Or just play safe?

It's the same with brands. Everything is high-stakes, like the semifinal. Every category is crowded. And it is going to get denser by the day; tougher to stand out in the rough sea. The unfair advantage, therefore, lies in the creative work we dish out. In the age of AI, when every other film has the same 'evening glow' grade and every girl looks the same, the onus lies with the brand custodian to push the agency to up the risk quotient. In fact, the narrative needs to shift from agency to the client.

Earlier, agencies were pushing for creative work; now clients need to push agencies for work that sticks. We may call it 'role reversal of creativity'.

Brands are under tremendous pressure to succeed. And they need to match that pressure with a campaign that looks and feels like a risk well taken. The idea is to even stop calling it 'risk', which has a negative strain.

On the other hand, people who consume advertising reward brands when they see a differentiated idea or a story they can relate to. Safe feels sanitised. It ticks all the boxes and remains confined in boxes.

People love to forget things that don't excite them. Clients today ask for an intrigue-generating 'first three seconds' for any digital ad. The magic opening. It's counter-intuitive if those first three seconds are safe. It's a miss.

The brand may exist on a store shelf but it remains invisible. And being invisible is the worst place to be in any brand's life. In fact, the brands that are still doing regular work and pushing agencies to do conformist stories, showing clichéd characters and 'addy' homes, are taking the biggest risk in their marketing journey. The most convenient reason which we may have heard across conference rooms is this: Our consumers won't get it.

Thankfully, things are changing. The new-age brands, D2C brands and the fintech brands, startups flush with money, are driving the creative narrative. The fundamental shift, if it happens at a larger scale, where safe advertising finds a safe coffin, we might hear creativity say, 'Risk hai toh Ishq hai.'

The author is founder, Philosophy Brand Solutions.

Source: MANIFEST MEDIA

Subscribe

* indicates required